205 Fairview Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

$3,595,000

A Rare Opportunity to Own a Piece of Montauk History. Step into an iconic Carl Fisher original—one of the last remaining homes from Fisher’s visionary plan to bring the charm and glamour of Miami Beach to Montauk. Thoughtfully revived and meticulously restored, this rare 1920s residence blends its unmistakable historic… Read More character with sophisticated modern enhancements, preserving every detail that makes it truly one of a kind. Historic Craftsmanship, Expertly Renewed Every inch of this four bedroom, three bath home has been lovingly brought back to life. A rebuilt slate roof, new copper gutters, classic stucco siding, and a welcoming courtyard-style entrance highlight the home’s revived architectural integrity. Blue slate patios and the distinctive garage roof with inset “birdhouses” pay homage to Fisher’s signature design elements. Inside, original cherry wood floors have been beautifully refinished, and the plaster walls have been expertly restored to their former charm. Light-Filled Living & Thoughtful Design The expansive living room impresses with vaulted ceilings, a wood burning fireplace, and an extended den/TV area—perfect for gathering and relaxation. The open, sunlit kitchen features custom Bear Mountain Woodworking cabinetry, a large center island with Carrera countertops, imported Belgian Blue Stone floors, and premium Viking and Bosch stainless steel appliances. A spacious formal dining room overlooks lush grounds and a brick-and-stone patio, seamlessly blending indoor and outdoor living. The first floor also includes a private guest bedroom with a stylish full bath. Honor to Revitalize Every design decision—every fixture, finish, and piece of furniture—was intentionally selected to honor and elevate the home’s historic soul. Private Bedroom Wings The second-level primary suite sits in its own private wing, offering generous closet space, a newly designed bath featuring an arched shower door, and a newly built balcony that extends the living experience outdoors. Maintaining the original floor plan, the home’s third and fourth bedrooms form a unique private wing spanning the second and third floors, complete with a full guest bath. An Unmatched Montauk Location Just minutes from the heart of town, Montauk Downs golf course, and the area’s celebrated ocean beaches, this home blends history, charm, and convenience. This is more than a residence—it’s a legacy. A rare chance to own a restored Carl Fisher original brought brilliantly back to life. Read Less

Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate.

Listing Snapshot

Days Online

Last Updated

Apr 9, 2026

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Beds

Full Baths

Square Ft.

2,936

Year Built

1925

Property Tax

$9,320

MLS Number

978891

30 Days Snapshot Of 11954

$815k

(avg) sold price

389

(avg) days on market

Snapshot

Area Map

Additional Details

Building

Year Built: 1925, Area: 2936, Architecture: "Traditional", Construction Materials: "Stucco"

Appliances & Equipment

Description: "Dishwasher", "Dryer", "Gas Range", "Microwave", "Stainless Steel Appliance(s)", "Washer"

Basement

Description: "Full"

Cooling

Details: "Ductless"

Garage

Garage Spaces: 2

Heating

Heating: "Hot Water", "Oil", "Radiant Floor"

Lot

Acres: 0.74

Utilities

Sewer: "Cesspool", Water Source: "Public", Utilities: "Cable Available", "Electricity Connected", "Water Connected"

Find The Perfect Home

'VIP' Listing Search

Whenever a listing hits the market that matches your criteria you will be immediately notified.

Join The List

Mortgage Calculator

Selling price

Down payment

Term (years)

Interest rate (%)

Monthly Payment

205 Fairview Avenue

'VIP' Listing Search

Schools In The Area

Similar Listings

Find My Dream Home

1. Neighborhoods

2. Home Type

3. Send

Sitemap

Get in touch